A Diver Found a $3 Million Gold Cross Hidden Under a Shipwreck. Then a Thief Replaced It With a Plastic Fake. 22%
By Tim Newcomb39%
8/4/2026, 5:00:00 AM
BS Summary: This article contains 23 faulty reasoning types, including Biased Writer Voice, Appeal to Authority, and Status Quo Bias, with Unattributed Quote as the most egregious example at 16.2% saturation with 148 hits. Analysis detected 1,050 faulty-reasoning hits from 913 analyzed words, generating a BS Score of 28.9% and a BS Rank of 22% (23,251 of 29,795 articles). This article is better (less manipulative) than 78.00% of the article peer group.
Former British Navy diver Teddy Tucker discovered over 100 shipwrecks in the waters surrounding Bermuda.
He recovered gold from the 1592 wreck of the Spanish San Pedro, including a gold cross featuring seven emeralds.
More than 20 years after the discovery, thieves swiped the cross prior to a visit from Queen Elizabeth II, never to be recovered.
When Teddy Tucker first discovered a shipwreck off the Bermuda shores in the 1950s, he kept his haul a secret, even tucking a three-inch gold cross studded with seven emeralds away in a closet.
Over 70 years later, what’s now known as Tucker’s Cross holds the story of a Spanish shipwreck, a queen’s visit, and a brazen unsolved heist.
A former British Navy diver trained in underwater demolition during World War II, Tucker settled back in Bermuda (where he was born) with his wife following the war, running a salvage business and getting to know local fisherman.
But that wasn’t all.
“I was going to look for treasure, there was no question about that,” Tucker said, according to his daughter, Wendy Tucker, who runs a website dedicated to her father.
“I started finding a lot of shipwrecks.”
By all accounts, Teddy Tucker discovered over 100 shipwrecks (including the 1621 Spanish wreck of the San Antonio, complete with 57 pieces of gold), but none were quite as intriguing as what turned out to be the 1592 shipwreck of the Spanish galleon the San Pedro.
After local fisherman told him about marble columns in the water, Tucker dove beneath the surface to see for himself.
In 1951, Tucker first discovered Spanish cannons.
He went back in 1955 and started sifting through sand, finding wood and porcelain before locating a five-sided gold cube with a Spanish tax stamp on the side.
He also found mortar with the date 1561 stamped on it.
He spent seven straight days returning to the site.
“This expedition was casting a different look on treasure hunting, which until now, had only been a dream or part of a fantasy world that everyone talks about, yet no one believes will ever become a reality,” he told his daughter.
“From that moment on my mild interest in treasure hunting changed.”
In the first six trips, he found gold ingots, a 36-ounce gold bar measuring 10 inches long, gold coins, and over 200 silver coins dating the ship to no earlier than 1592.
On the seventh day, after diving 30 feet below the surface with a facemask and flippers, the real treasure surfaced.
“There was a big plank of some part of the ship, probably a hull plank or something,” he said.
“Just lifted it up and slid it away and there was a cross face down under it.
And it was bright gold.
I knew it was gold.
I’d found gold before and seen a bit of it.
Picked it up, turned it up, emeralds!”
The emeralds, each the size of a musket ball, shone with the the “green fire” Tucker had heard emeralds were known for—plus, he knew glass would have oxidized and frosted.
While he described the find as beautiful, he said it was still a crude carving, likely from the Americas and not made by a Spanish craftsman.
Tucker took the cross home and stashed it in his closet—he also tried to clear the site, so as to make it not look like a shipwreck to other would-be hunters.
Word still got out.
At three inches by 1.5 inches, with a removable cover on the back revealing an empty compartment, the 22-karat gold and emerald piece drew both attention and lucrative purchaseoffers.
Life published a feature on the find, calling it “one of the most valuable pieces of sunken treasure ever found.”
All the publicity put both Tucker and his cross in the spotlight, which is what he had tried to avoid.
He was followed by treasure hunters every time he went to sea, hoping he’d reveal the site of the shipwreck.
Eventually, Smithsonian Institute expert Mendel Peterson visited Bermuda and valued the treasure at $250,000 (over $3 million in today’s money).
Despite a dispute with the government of Bermuda over the treasure’s ownership, Tucker eventually sold the entire San Pedro collection to the government, including the cross, in 1959.
While reports of the sale price vary, by all accounts, it sold for far below its worth.
Tucker’s connection to the cross doesn’t end there.
Still considered one of the single most valuable items ever pulled from a shipwreck, the object was originally displayed at the Bermuda Aquarium, and was moved to the Bermuda Maritime Museum in 1975 ahead of Queen Elizabeth II’s scheduled visit to the museum.
Officials invited Tucker to come and act as a museum guide for the queen, but when he saw the cross again, he knew something was amiss.
It was too dull.
Wendy Tucker said her father picked it up and paint came off in his hand.
He was holding a plastic replica so new the paint wasn’t fully dry.
The queen never knew of the theft, and the FBI and Interpol made no headway on the heist.
The cross was never relocated.
Tucker, who died in 2014 at the age of 89, told his daughter that the “cross remains my most treasured discovery,” even if there may be no hope of its recovery this time.
Speakers
1speaker5.6%attributed speech862writer words
Selected voice
100%flagged-word coverageWendy Tucker
51 attributed words100% of attributed speech78% writer coverage
Attribution is sentence-level. Pattern percentages are calculated only from words assigned to that voice.
Loading…
Loading…
Loading…
Loading…
Analysis
Hover over highlighted words in the article to view the associated bias or fallacy analysis.